The Queen of Black Magic
WARNING : looter ahead forThe Queen Of Black Magic
TheShudderoriginal tone ending , The queer Of Black Magic , is a remaking of a 1981 Indonesian Graeco-Roman supernatural horror flick of the same name , but how do the two compare to each other ? aim by Kimo Stamboel and written by Joko Anwar , the movie keep an eye on a group of friends who venture back to their orphanhood to say their final goodbyes to their health care provider , while Lilik Sudjio ’s work goes in an altogether dissimilar route . In fact , there are so many differences that it would be more appropriate to see 2021’sThe Queen Of Black Magicas a movie establish on the original , not a lineal remake .
Throughout 2020,foreign repulsion moviesbecame increasingly prevailing on major cyclosis divine service such as Netflix and Shudder . Indonesian film writer and director Joko Anwar became fairly well - have it off in 2020 follow the release of his folk repugnance movieImpetigore . It notably subverted traditional tropes and melodic theme of the sub - music genre while providing perceptiveness into folk legends and mythology in Indonesia . Impetigorewas recently nominated for theBest Foreign Language Film Oscar , which it is more than merit of gain ground . With such a creative and modern screenwriter who draws from his own culture with such a keen eye for detail and purpose , The Queen Of Black Magicmakes for another telling summation to Anwar ’s repertory . Kimo Stamboel has been bond to several horror movies as well , includingDreadOutandMacabre . The two joined force to make this incredibly haunting supernatural horror enigma that holds its audience ’s attention from start to destination .
Related : How Impetigore get away Midsommar ’s Folk Horror expectation
Traditionally , remakes conform to some semblance of the original motion-picture show ’s plot , but that ’s not necessarily the case withThe Queen Of Black Magic . It hold back the same canonic chemical element of the 1981 motion-picture show , but alters characters , situations , tip of view , and the overall storyline . It ’s slightly standardized to what horror author Stephen King tried to attain with his adaptation of Shirley Jackson’sThe Haunting Of Hill House , which eventually turn intoRose Red . The substructure is there , but everything else was spay to fit a more cohesive and captivating story . A thorough viewing of 1981’sThe Queen Of Black Magicreveals just how many differences there are from this Shudder original movie — here ’s every major difference between the two movies , explained .
The Queen Of Black Magic’s Setting
While the setting of 1981’sThe Queen Of Black Magicencompasses a pocket-sized village in Indonesia , 2021 ’s takes place entirely at an orphanhood . This is largely due to the changes that Anwar made to the original movie , which ultimately ameliorate the plot line while also refine a few aspects of it as well . The orphanage is the placement where Murni ( Putri Ayudya ) became the pouf of black magic as a resolution of her mother ’s ( Ms. Mirah ) inequitable execution by its caretaker . Thus , therevenge plot of the storyis introduce , but only within the last half of the movie . Perhaps , if it had been at the forefront , it could ’ve bettered the impact of what was happening to the characters . At the same time , it does total a level of mystique . However , it must be notice thatThe Queen Of Black Magic’s1981 fructify did allow for the filmmaker to fix Murni ’s revenge at the very beginning .
The Queen Of Black Magic’s Point Of View
The point of view is entirely different between the 1981 film and the 2021 remake . While Liliek Sudjio’sThe Queen Of Black Magicis tell apart through Murni ’s eye , Stamboel and Anwar ’s movie focuses on the perspective of the mathematical group returning to the orphanage . More specifically , it hone in on Hanif ’s , who is portrayed by Ario Bayu ofImpetigore .
concern : The Best Horror Movies on Shudder Right Now
By altering this point of view , it makes Murni ’s revenge less powerful , as the 1981 feature showcases a fair sex who was wrongfully accuse of black conjuration fighting back against those who cause her harm . alternatively , 2021’sThe Queen Of Black Magicmakes it seem as though her desire for revenge is n’t entirely justified , as she kills whoever crossbreed her , even the children .
Why The Queen Of Black Magic Seeks Revenge
Stamboel and Anwar ’s Murni seeks retaliation because the girl ’s mother was wrongfully accuse of being a witch after Pak Bandi ( Yayu Unru ) , the caretaker of the orphans' asylum , poison three unseasoned little girl . He did so because he was sexually assaulting them and require to send a substance to the others that he would do the same to them if they were to tell the woman who cared for them — Murni ’s mother . To cover all of his fundament , he asserts that she ’s a witch , leading Hanif and his Quaker to interlace her in a room where she pounded her foreland on the door so firmly that it crack . It ’s mentioned in passing that she opt to perfect in on bootleg magic , which would align with the 1981 movie , as the wrongdoings done to Murni extend her to use it , but it ’s never fully developed . The 2021 variant of Murni wants revenge for her mother , who was unjustly killed and buried on the property . In the 1981 pic , Murni is the one who is unjustly accused of using black illusion , leading her to actually use it as a form of retaliation . These are entirely two different type of payback . One pertains to the self , while the other seeks retribution for a major going .
Every Major Change To Murni’s Character
Murni ’s character is not the same at all . In fact , there are so many difference between 1981 ’s Murni and 2021 ’s Murni that they should n’t even be considered the same person . For instance , Sudjio ’s titular character only apply it in parliamentary law to teach everyone a lesson , but she finds that the harm she caused was just as speculative as the violence that she experienced . She sees the erroneous belief of her path and apologizes with her last dying breathing place .
Related : Shudder ’s 2020 Original Horror Movies Ranked From Worst To Best
Stamboel and Anwar ’s Murni is vengeful through and through , she does not feel uncollectible about anything she is doing . Even as she tortures the children , she asserts that it is only rationalize , as they are a product of their sire , who played a hand at taking her female parent from her . Murni is a vicious exploiter of black magic and has ostensibly no cashable qualities , especially since her mother ’s sole intent at the orphanage was to keep the children safe and her daughter is going directly against that .
The Queen Of Black Magic’s Message
Both picture show foreground opprobrious pattern in man , which Anwar made a key breaker point inImpetigoreas well . It delves into the dangers perceived by women with king ( witches ) , how unseasoned girls can be preyed on by men like Bandi , and the desire for revenge women may experience , which has also been recently detail in movies such as 2020’sPromising Young Woman . While the 1981 version ofThe Queen Of Black Magicis drastically different from its 2021 remake , bothcritique women ’s place in bon ton through a repulsion lens and addimportant societal and political commentaryto the genre .
More : All 11 Shudder Original Horror Movies Releasing In Early 2021
