Gone With the Wind
Summary
There are several films that depict the American Civil War , but some of these motion picture contain glaring historic inaccuracies . While it ’s not possible to get everything correct about a well - document period in chronicle , some flick about the American Civil War seem to immix fact with fabrication . Great care has always been get when it number to the depiction of the American Civil War , and some of thebest Civil War moviesmake an endeavor to stay as close to story as potential .
Others , however , fall short on that front . For example , run With the Windisn’t just problematical because of its depiction of wash . Several historic experts have outlined how the movie does not accurately represent the damage the American Civil War left in its wake . As entertaining as the American Civil War movies are , it ’s crucial to take note that they are not a form of education . While it ’s possible to learn about chronicle from movies , it ’s dependable to commend that these narratives are unremarkably a dramatization of events .
9The Outlaw Josey Wales (1976)
The Outlaw Josey Walesis a 1976 movie from Clint Eastwood that tackles the American Civil War . The moving picture follow Josey Wales , a former Confederate soldier whose family is off by Union soldiers . A grief - stricken Wales is determined to go after the soldiers and avenge his family . While Wales was a substantial person — and he did reenact fierceness on Union soldiers — there are some inaccuracies to Eastwood ’s interpretation of the character . Most notably , the real - life Wales did n’t snipe Union soldier because he lost his family to them ( viaNotes From the Frontier ) .
8Shenandoah (1965)
The 1965 Civil War movieShenandoahfollows Charlie Anderson , a restrained farmer who has no interest in joining the state of war until one of his sons is captured by Union soldiers . One of the good things about the movie is how it mull over the cultural and racial geological fault after the 1964 Civil Rights Act . However , there is a scene that shows Black and white soldiers in the same platoon . That ’s not historically accurate , as the U.S. armed forces was segregate until after World War II ( viaEmerging Civil War ) . Despite this inaccuracy , the picture is still a sweeping tale about the moral quandary the great unwashed faced during the Civil War .
7Lincoln (2012)
Steven Spielberg’sLincolnis think one of the honest movies describe the American Civil War . base on Doris Kearn ’s novel , A Team of Rivals , Lincolntells the narration of Abraham Lincoln during the Civil War and the passageway of the 13th Amendment . As good asLincolnis , it ’s difficult to get every detail aright when a flick is base on a tangible - sprightliness historic figure . However , the movie does get a few things correct , including Lincoln ’s voice , his love of storytelling , and the pardon he give recreant . That being said , there are still some questions concern tohow accurateLincolnis .
AlthoughLincolnis more accurate than some Civil War picture , the movie gets some thing wrong . For instance , the picture of Lincoln ’s 1865 locker being full of political rivals is n’t precise . alternatively of being full of political rivals , Lincoln ’s cabinet was full of loyalists who were on his side . The movie also showed Lincoln swan at his console and hitting his son . As far as diachronic records go , Lincoln seldom avow , and there is no evidence that he was opprobrious toward his son . Most of the changes made in regard to historical truth were merely for dramatic design ( viaFree term of enlistment by Foot ) .
6Cold Mountain (2003)
moth-eaten Mountainis a lovemaking story that is set against the backdrop of one of the bloodiest wars in American history . ground on Charles Frazier ’s best - sell novel of the same name , the critically acclaim movie tells the story of a Confederate soldier who forsake the warfare so as to be with his genuine love . According to ahistorians ' follow-up of Jude Law ’s historic romance , the movie used its originative license liberally . Cold Mountaindoes not accurately depict how Ada would have looked if she were truly toiling on the farm . She ’s always made up and put together despite the type of body of work she ’s doing ( viaHistory Goes to the Movies ) .
Cold Mountainalso does not render how loyal people were to the Union . If a soldier abandon , the Union soldiers would not only hunt them down but look for their kinsfolk as well . There ’s a scenery in the movie about a turkey shoot , and that ’s overstated . During the turkey shoot , the bomb calorimeter did n’t go off , have one brave soldier to go in and go down it off . or else , in the picture show , the soldiers put up sandbags and hide behind them when they should have gibe if the fuse was lit ( viaInsider ) .
5Glory (1989)
Gloryis a word picture of the first African - American regiment in the northern states , called the 54th Massachusetts . The moving picture was integral in showing that there were , in fact , African - American soldiers in the federal Army . Even though that ’s exact , there are some scenes that used the good old Hollywood flair . It ’s not historically accurate that Black soldier had to scramble to see near equipment or that they were escaped subject area hands . Governor Andrews in reality cautiously prefer the soldiers and ensured that they had all the equipment they needed to fight in the war ( viaThe Kansas City Public Library ) .
The 30 - class - old Civil War movie Gettysburg ages well with its approximate perfect depiction of battle scene , according to historian Garry Adelman .
4The Good, The Bad And The Ugly (1995)
Clint Eastwood’sThe Good , the Bad and the Ugly , follow three gunslingers as they search for bury Confederate amber . Despite the motion picture being one of Eastwood ’s smashing kit and caboodle , history experts criticized its historic inaccuracy . One of the glaring inaccuracies inThe Good , the Bad and the Uglyis the use of Gatling guns . While it is true that Gatling guns were used in the Civil War , they were not used in 1862 , nor were they around in New Mexico during the period depicted in the movie . Additionally , it ’s not accurate that a mathematical group of 80 soldier charged against the enemy . That was simply not done at the metre ( viaInsider ) .
Clint Eastwood ’s iconic 57 - year - old Western gets assessed by a polite warfare expert and receive a brutally tough rating for its historic accuracy .
3Gettysburg (1993)
Based on Michael Shaara ’s novelKiller Angels , Gettysburggives an account of the three - dayGe ttysburg battle . Gettysburggets a lot correct , but there are some thing about the movie that warrant a closer look . The fact that Union Major General George Meade ’s importance to the warfare is n’t highlighted in the picture does it a slap-up disservice . Even though he was as important to the state of war as Robert E. Lee , he ’s hardly seen in the movie . to boot , Lee ’s conversations are highly exaggerated . They in reality did not peach that much during the fight of Gettysburg ( viaEmerging Civil War ) .
2Andersonville (1996)
Andersonvilleis loosely ground on a true story about John Ransom . The movie follow a group of soldiers who are captured during the Battle of Cold Harbor . The catch men are transported to a frightful Confederate prison . Andersonvillehas been praised for bring the horrible conditions present in the Confederate prison house camp to luminosity . However , some fit in the movie are not historically accurate . For instance , its depiction of prisoner exchanges is not naturalistic . Prisoner exchanges were a frequent occurrence , so a soldier captured at the Battle of Antietam in 1862 would n’t be there two years later ( viaHistory Net ) .
1Gone With The Wind (1939)
The 1939 movieGone With the Windwas always problematic . Granted , it ’s a moving picture of its meter , but some scenes in the flick could have been made with more tending . The main job withGone With the Windis its one - sided portrayal of the Civil War . Not only that , but its picture of well-chosen plantations and content slaves is inaccurate . go With the Winddoes nothing to transmit the true horrors of the American Civil War . The true story is color over to favour a plot that would sit better with audiences ( viaEmerging Civil War ) .
source : Notes From the Frontier , emerge Civil War , Free Tours by Foot , History Goes to the Movies , Insider , The Kansas City Public Library , Insider , Emerging Civil War , History Net , emerge Civil War
