Related
TheHarry Potteruniverse is live for its fantastic mysteries . Reading those book was like traveling down an endless dungeon , with novel twists and tincture around every corner . However , most of those mystery were answer at the end of Deathly Hallows . Or were they ?
Despite the many question that J.K. Rowling did do at the oddment of her serial publication , there were still a few mystery that never got resolve . Some might be small things only die - laborious devotee notice , while others are major puzzler that could be considered plot of ground kettle of fish . Still , they all contribute to the lore ofHarry Potter .
update on December 14th , 2022 , by David Caballero : As talk of a novel episode in the Harry Potter series grow stiff , sports fan might find in the mood to revisit the sorcerous and aliveness - changing series . Re - read the books is just as incredible as the first time , but fans might mark some questions that never received a right answer . And although more entropy about the Wizarding World comes out every Clarence Day , these enigma seem doomed to go unreciprocated forever .
Where Does Magic Come From?
Perhaps the biggest secret of them all is the origin of the magic trick that permeates thePotteruniverse . The account book never devil to excuse the history of magic . They at times advert a far-famed legendary wizard and sometimes name - free fall a significant historic bod ; however , they never go into item about the origins of magic .
In fact , no character seems interested in discovering more about the nascence of their power , not even Hermione . It ’s a disgrace because the origin of conjuring trick is arguably a far more intriguing and compelling story than yet another wizarding warfare against another malign wizard . Now that theFantastic Beastsfranchise is dead , perhaps a succeeding Potter twisting - off can centre on solving this interrogative sentence .
Why Is Professor McGonagall In Fantastic Beasts?
Minerva McGonagall is one of the wisest characters inHarry Potter . Tough as nails and powerful , McGonagall is arguably the best teacher in Hogwarts and a crucial mentor for Harry and his friend . McGonagall is among the most popular characters in the serial publication , which might explain why Warner Bros. would want to include her in the Hogwarts scenes duringThe Crimes of Grindelwald .
However , the dates do n’t sum up up . InOrder of the Phoenix , McGonagall says she ’s been teach at Hogwarts for 39 years , meaning she start work at the school in 1956 , near thirty years after the events ofThe Crimes of Grindelwald . Seems like Jo mess up up jolly badly on this one .
What’s The Wizarding World Stance On Monarchy?
TheHarry Potterseries is a jolly straightforward reflection of modern Britain . It has a Minister of Magic , a lightly - veiled reference to the Prime Minister , and Hogwarts is an adaption of many embarkation British schools . However , there ’s no mention of what the Wizarding World thinks of the monarchy , nor is there an equivalent of the Royal Family in the serial .
If the Minister of Magic introduces himself to the PM , should n’t he do the same with the senior members of the Royal Family ? At least the Queen should know about the beingness of illusion . So why does n’t she ? And why does the series disregard such a crucial part of British culture ?
How Does The Deluminator Work?
Ron is a misunderstood character . The movies ruined his character by turning him into comic easement , but the books do a fine occupation portray him as an unsafe unseasoned man shin to find himself . Ron receives the Deluminator from Dumbledore , presumably because Dumbledore sympathize Ron ’s jealousy and insecurity .
However , the Deluminator ’s nature is wispy and too commodious . There ’s never any explanation of how it works or its purpose . It ’s unclear if it only works with Ron or can help others . In short , it feels more like a plot twist than a truly clever magical tool .
Why Do The Other Magical Schools Never Get Mentioned?
For such an impressive tale , the worldbuilding inHarry Potterfeels surprisingly circumscribed and minuscule - plate . Rowling goes into contingent about the UK but never put out to mention how magic operate in other parts of the world . Beauxbattons and Durmstrang come in the quaternary book , but they never feel like dependable institutions on par with Hogwarts .
Why are the other wizarding school never bring up ? Why is there only one school for South America and one for Africa ? Is sorcerous more powerful in Europe ? The wizarding humanity is presuppose to be vast and inclusive , yet the books never show these qualities .
Why On Earth Didn’t Dumbledore Take Better Care Of Harry?
Dumbledore ’s decision to send Harry with the Dursleys is graspable . As fell as it may have seemed , the headmaster did it to keep Harry safe from Voldemort . The son Who Lived had to reside somewhere where his mother ’s blood still hold up . But why on globe did n’t he ensure the Dursleys were skillful to Harry ?
Dumbledore did n’t have to shroud his magic from the family unit ; they knew who he was , and Petunia was distinctly afraid of him . Had Dumbledore threaten to contain on Harry now and then , it should have frightened them enough to be kinder , especially as they would n’t require the neighbor to see Dumbledore show up on their doorsill .
What Was The Backstory Between Dumbledore And Fawkes
Fawkes the phoenix became an essential part of theHarry Potterseriesin ways few people could have guessed when he was first introduced . Not only was he Dumbeldore ’s darling favourite , but he saved Harry ’s life , delivered warning , and his tail feathers were even used in the duplicate cores of Harry and Voldemort ’s wands .
Yet Dumbledore and Fawkes ' history is never explored or even hint at in the books . Guy Fawkes may be a pet , but he ’s important , as most named animals in the serial publication are . It seems strange that he was one of the only unity who never had a backstory .
Why Weren’t James And Lily Each Other’s Secret Keepers?
The Fidelius Charm kickstarted the issue of the entire serial publication . Voldemort was hunt James and Lily , so Dumbledore suggested they use a Fidelius Charm to keep them safe . They would choose a privy Keeper , and if that someone did n’t reveal the Potter ’s location , Voldemort would never regain them .
plainly , Peter becomes the Secret Keeper and tell on them , but why did n’t James and Lily serve as each other ’s Secret Keepers alternatively ? Would n’t that have been the safest choice ?
Snape’s Favoritism Of Draco Malfoy Doesn’t Make Any Sense
Severus Snape is not a fan of Harry Potter . He has a strong distaste for the male child Who populate due to his similarities to his father . The massive reveal about Snape ’s love for Lily and his fight to keep Harry alive was a game - changer , but the prof ’s dislike for Harry never changed .
In Snape ’s eyes , Harry is as arrogant and cocky as his dad was , even though that is really not true at all . But why would he play favorites with Draco , who share many of the trait Snape claimed to hate in James than Harry ever had ? Draco was the loathsome and arrogant hind end , not Harry .
What Did Magical Children Do Until They Turned 11?
Young witches and magician receive their letters to Hogwarts upon their eleventh natal day , and then their wizard journeys really begin . But what do those kids do before they turn 11 ? Harry went to a muggle public school , which makes mother wit since the Dursleys wanted to squash the magic out of him .
Most Muggle - born kids probably have a normal upbringing at a Muggle schooling , too . But what about virgin - bred families ? Did the Weasley children go to a muggle school day ? Did they just sit around all day for year until their Hogwarts letter get ?
Where Were American Wizards During Voldemort’s First Rise?
TheFantastic Beastsfranchise bring the wizarding world ofHarry Potteracross the sea to the United States . For the first fourth dimension , consultation saw American and British wizards work together to stop a great terror . So why are the Americans nowhere to be seen during the warfare against Voldemort ?
The danger that Voldemort posed stretched far beyond Hogwarts and the UK , so why did n’t American wizards avail to stop him ? On the insolent side , where were Voldemort ’s American agents ? Grindelwald set his dream for world mastery , whereas Voldemort seemed focussed on the UK;perhaps Grindelwald is the superior Wizarding World villain , after all .
What’s The Deal With The Brains In Jars?
The aspect in the " Department of Mysteries " room at the Ministry of Magic stay gravel . There ’s wad to enquire about – the Department of Mysteries lives up to its name – , but those brains in jars stomach out above all other questions .
grant to the book , the brains were there " to study intellection , " but how was the Ministry studying thought ? And who the heck did those brain belong to ? J.K. Rowling had a lot of inhalation forHarry Potter , from Norse mythology to Arthurian legend . But Young Frankenstein is n’t an IP that comes to thinker when think about the Wizarding World .
Where Did The Basilisk Come From?
Speaking of ominously names rooms , there ’s a lot of closed book still to the Chamber of Secrets . What was Salazar Slytherin doing in there ? For that matter , what was Tom Riddle ? But even if we can guess at those , we still do n’t have the solution to one of the biggest ( literally ) mysteries about that station : the stemma of the basilisk .
We know the basilisk is a rare and horrific creature in the wizarding world , so how did Salazar get his hands on one ? Did he hatch one himself ? And if so , why did he keep it in the Chamber ? The whodunit surrounding the basilisk makes it all the more terrific .
How Does Colin Creevey’s Camera Work?
Chamber of Secretsis full of unreciprocated motion . Take Colin Creevey ’s television camera , ostensibly a muggle equipment . However , readers learn that muggle devices do n’t work in Hogwarts two Koran later .
So how does galling Colin ’s television camera take the exposure it does ? Is it somehow enchanted , able to flex the tour around Hogwarts ? Or is something more forbidding at play ; is Colin Creevey actually one of the most powerful mavin in the Harry Potter universe , capable to interrupt magic that even Voldemort and Dumbledore themselves ca n’t evade ?
How Can Voldemort Curse The Defense Against the Dark Arts Teaching Position?
Things do n’t go well forthe Hogwarts Defense Against the Dark Arts teachers . finally , the books expose it ’s because of a literal curse Voldemort placed on the status . But how could he do that ? How could Voldemort unchurch not just a person or an physical object but a business deed ?
The reveal seems more like Rowling trying to be clever and bring in it seem like the plot of ground was always in the works . However , it ’s probable that she saw a chance to splice everything with a neat fore and did n’t care about the minutia of how the curse would solve .
Why Does Harry Potter Need Glasses?
Harry Potter can talk to snakes . He can walk around without being seen in an invisibility cloak and can even pilot . So why , in the name of all that is magic , does he not unsex his vision ? ? Harry , in Hermione ’s dustup , has an " terrible " sight . Yet he seems content with his spectacles , to the point where he uses deception to posit his one-time specs .
Why , then , can he not just take some of his magic and cure his astigmatism ? Is it just because Daniel Radcliffe calculate salutary in glassful ? Harry does n’t seem to have an overt attachment to the eyeglasses , make the mystery of their comportment even greater .
What Ever Happened To Sally-Anne Perks?
Harry ’s classmates made pretty regular appearances throughout the series , albeit in modest , sometimes scarcely - noticeable part . Except for Sally - Anne Perks . Sally - Anne was sorted right before Harry Potter , and then she just … disappears . She ’s never called on again for any Hogwarts activities , nor does Rowling observe her after the first Good Book .
So where did Sally - Anne go ? The best typeface is that she survive off to a unlike school , perhaps in a whizz substitution syllabus . Worst case ? Well , maybe the jokes about Thomas Kid disappearing during Quidditch were not just jokes . Hogwarts ' students also delight catch into trouble , so perhaps Sally - Anne bit more than he could chew .
What’s The Secret Behind Moody’s Eye?
Mad - Eye Moody was one of the most visual character in theHarry Pottercanon , not just because of his trenchant look . Moody literally had a magic eye in place of one he lost in his job as an Auror , and the switch is one of the most mystifying target inHarry Potterlore .
It can see Harry even under his invisibility cloak , a exploit other conjuror , including decease himself , could not extract off . What ’s the story behind this mystical optical target ? Where did it come from , and what were its true capabilities ? Moody died taking those secrets to his grave .
What Is The Veil?
One of the most tragic dying in theHarry Potterlorehappens within the Department of Mysteries : Sirius Black . But right after this scarring , tragical event also add up one of the unusual moments in the Potterverse as Sirius passes through a variety of doorframe , a curtained window into another world .
This passageway is only referred to as " the veil , " with the book suggesting it ’s some kind of bridge deck between the deadly and spiritual worlds . But what is the association ? The Veil is calamitous to anyone who pass through it , but why is it there ? Is it the gateway between life and dying ? If so , how do some soul not pass through it ? Like death itself , the Veil is a dark and convoluted motion .
How Do You Make A Horcrux?
Horcruxes are the nastiest and evil artifact in the Wizarding World . Their world remains a mystery , and it will never get an reply . The books paint a picture execution require to happen to break a person ’s soul ; however , the item of the process are still under wrap .
According to an consultation withPotterCast , Rowling admit that she knew how Horcruxes were made , even hinting that she wanted to include the account in the Book . However , her editor claimed it was too blue . What was so sinister that it could n’t be let in in a book about branch - severing , nipper - murdering , psychopathic champion Nazis ? Whatever the answer , it must have been moderately bad .
NEXT:10 Worst Harry Potter Movie Plot Holes That Were excuse In The record book
