Related
Some characters have so much longevity that they keep being convey back to screens , growing even more memorable when a legendary actor play them . Many of them have had risky venture in lit , on TV shows , and in moving picture theater . Then there are the reboots , remakes and reimaginings . When a great worker brings to life a fiber in a room that ’s quite plainly perfect , it ’s a hard human action to follow , yet clip and sentence again , film producer try and recreate the magic of what once was .
Certain roles have been taken on by multiple actors , to vary levels of success . The ravisher of cinema is that there ’s always something for somebody . So , while one person may prefer Anne Hathaway ’s variation of Catwoman , or debate Winona Ryder vs Saoirse Ronan asLittle Women ’s Jo March , there ’s not always a good or wrong answer . However , it ’s fair to say that some fabled actors have staked a strong title on certain characters , while some have failed to capture their essence in a recognizable way when attempting to reanimate orreinvent an iconic character .
10James Bond
Sean Connery vs. George Lazenby
Ian Fleming ’s undercover agent novels made it to the big screen for the first clock time in 1962 whenDr . Nointroduced the world to Bond , James Bond . Played by Sean Connery , the persona had magic spell , personal magnetism and a sensuality that dominated the filmdom . He seduced many woman in the film , as well as the numberless viewers watching his high - octane antics . His character of hypermasculinity is a agency of a specific second in fourth dimension , and for the aim of a knavish MI6 spy , it work very well . There have been countless debates about who the adept Bond actor is , and while there ’s not much of a consensus on that , there most certainly is when it comes to who the worst one is .
According to British bookmakers , Irish actor Paul Mescal is now the 2d most likely to be disgorge as James Bond . For a foresighted clock time , Aaron Taylor - Johnson was been the favorite to take over the James Bond franchise , but following the spillage of Gladiator 2 , Mescal ’s betting odds have risen to 2/1 . I cerebrate he could be an interesting Bond , but I ’m not holding my breath yet . It ’s been a while since a Bond was last cast , and with the means the world has alter over the year , I think the franchise is taking its clip in picking the new 007 .
George Lazenby ’s one - time foray into James Bond ’s worldof martinis and espionage was not well receive , and continues to be one of audiences ' least favorite of the dealership . He lacked Connery ’s gritstone or even Roger Moore ’s suave sophistication , and Pierce Brosnan ’s classy hardness . There were many contributing factors that led to Lazenby not returning to the character , but had he made a giving impact , maybe it would have turned out differently . Sir Sean Connery was back just two days later .
9Samantha Stephens / Isabel Bigelow
Elizabeth Montgomery vs Nicole Kidman
Bewitchedwas hugely popular during its 254 - instalment foot race , and had a very long hereafter in syndication worldwide . Putting a sitcom spin on witchcraft , the quirky drollery showcased Elizabeth Montgomery ’s fille - next - door charisma in every sequence as she navigated married life with a deadly . The jokes down well in the neat - cutting landscape painting of television at the meter , and it ’s still a pleasant spotter with a twinge of nostalgia . The film remaking that starred Nicole Kidman lacked any of the magic of the original , with no observable chemistry between the lead and a serious shortage of jape . It holds 23 % on Rotten Tomatoes .
Kidman is , of form , an Oscar - winning doer , so her ability is not in doubt .
While the film tries to put a twist on the format by setting it in the current day and take a story within a story , the good luck charm of the master is clearly missing . Kidman is , of course , an Oscar - winning actor , so her power is not in question . However , sometimes the casting is everything , and if someone does n’t quite have the discharge , it ’s unmistakable to see .
8Superman
Christopher Reeve vs. Brandon Routh
Clark Kent has been take to life onscreen more times than most , but the originative portrayal isChristopher Reeve ’s edition in the 1978Supermanfilm and its sequels . While Kirk Alyn and George Reeves had both playact the Kryptonian in the ' 40s and ' 50s in America , Richard Donner’sSupermanbrought this more modern version to consultation all over the world . The picture find three Oscar nominations and was a bighearted corner authority hit , with Reeve ’s Man of Steel becoming the poster boy for heroism . This remained so well into the 1990s and 2000s when two successful TV show reimagined his story .
Then the " Superman curse " struck , where calamity bechance many of those involved in the enfranchisement . Most notably , Christopher Reeve suffered a horrific accident that left him paralyzed from the neck down . There had not been a cinematic translation until 2006 , whenSuperman Returnswas released . Brandon Routh was land in to bring the leash . The film underperformed on many levels , with Routh ’s carrying into action not receiving the universal acclaim that Reeve had enjoyed . The fact that it was a standalone film , and the next one did n’t come out for another 10 years speaks for itself .
7Alfie
Michael Caine vs Jude Law
In the other 2000s Jude Law was everywhere . He’d had a vast find withThe Talented Mr. Ripley , and showcased his mark of English charm in many photographic film at the time . In theory , his high visibility and wide - ranging charm should have served the function of human - about - time Alfie well , but this was not the case . In the hands of Sir Michael Caine , he was a witty and mischievous character , very brash but the audience commiserate with him .
The 1966 film was critically well - received and even received five Academy Award nomination .
Jude Law ’s Alfie is for the most part unlikable , and the film lacked the appeal of the original . Even though neither movie was a tremendously high profile project , the archetype has a loyal lover home and a type of acclaim the remake failed to achieve . Jude Law , while a suave and seductive lead man , did n’t show enough of his softer side to pull off this particular part .
6The Genie
Robin Williams vs Will Smith
Disney films in the 1990s reached another level of popularity , garnering Oscar nominations and begin to dabble in casting big stars to voice their characters . Robin Williams defined the role of genie for many generation , so step into his curly - toed horseshoe was always move to be unmanageable . When the era of resilient - action remake was in full swinging , theAladdin2019 remake castWill Smith in the unexampled role . He did not do a bad chore by any stretch , bringing some of his own panache to the purpose .
While Smith is funny and magnetic , does a slap-up job with the call and has a dandy resonance with his Aladdin , his predecessor was too hard an enactment to follow . The original renovate feature rest superior on many tier . It could be argued that the CGI was n’t quite as comforting as the original animation , and that hearingFriend Like Mein any voice that was n’t Williams ' might be too atrocious even to this daylight .
5Bodhi and Johnny Utah/Utah
Patrick Swayze and Keanu Reeves vs Edgar Ramírez and Luke Bracey
Universally regarded as one of the worst remake of recent memory , this retelling of 1991’sPoint Breakwas quite plainly unnecessary . While there are many movie remakes that do n’t bring too much nuance to the tale , they might at least offer a fresh take or a different angle.21 Jump Streetbecame a drollery , Jumanjiintroduced more natural process and deal of gags relate to new technology , andItwas able-bodied to offer more theatrical role depth and better optic effects .
ThePoint Breakremake offer none of that , andits champion lack the leading man vigor offered by Swayze and Reeves respectively . What was once a mettlesome thriller , with unequalled shots , and a complicated moral force between the two champion , becomes a run - of - the - mill popcorn flick with no heart . Edgar Ramírez and Luke Bracey , though both competent and full of energy , neglect to recapture the magic trick of the fad classic on many levels .
4Joker
Heath Ledger vs Jared Leto
The Joker has had many faces over the years , each aiming to put their own twist on this rich character . Cesar Romero ’s campy reading was a bang in the 1960s , and Jack Nicholson injected an extra layer of evil into his uneasy delineation . But it wasHeath Ledger ’s version of Joker inThe Dark Knightthat was the first to make this clownish villain seem more human and more terrifying than ever . He gave so much to this twisted function that he even accommodate that it had impacted him mentally . Sadly , in a way that ended in tragedy .
Other than appearances in animated shows , the DC scoundrel was n’t seen on the magnanimous screenland until Jared Leto ’s portrayal inSuicide Squad .
His Joker earned Ledger a posthumous Oscar , and rest one of the most memorable and darling iteration of the case . Other than appearances in liven display , the DC villain was n’t seen on the big screen door until Jared Leto ’s portrayal inSuicide Squad . Understandably , he did n’t need to ill-treat like a shot into his predecessor ’s shoes , but the lackluster two - dimensional interpretation was a universal dashing hopes . He has not reprize this role since , and with DC shifting gears , not to refer Joaquin Phoenix , it ’s unlikely he ever will .
3Chief Inspector Clouseau
Peter Sellers vs Steve Martin
Despite the theatrical role ’s foul up behavior , Peter Sellers brought a jot of course and sophistication to his version of the French sleuthhound . Though constantly finding himself in outlandish situation , he still seems capable at his job . The pinkish Panthermovies of the 1960s and 1970s mixed comedy with a really interesting whodunit , making each of the six official pleasure trip both funny and engaging .
Steve Martin , on the other hand , pick out to fully embrace the clumsy worthlessness which resulted in over - the - top muzzle and lack of any form of intrigue . It had take in a while to bestow the story back to the filmdom , and perhaps it should have taken even more . The film did n’t hold out up to its outlook and failed to reanimate this darling fiber . There was n’t enough nostalgia for the older viewers , and even the inclusion of Beyoncè could n’t get the younger generation onboard .
2Catwoman
Michelle Pfeiffer vs Halle Berry
Both Tim Burton ’s versions of Batman utilized his sorry imaginativeness to perfection , creating a whimsical world of caped crusader and masked vigilantes . It never felt completely realistic , instead having that comic book and svelte fairy tale pang to it . Michelle Pfeiffer ’s version of Selena Kyle , aka Catwoman , primed into this imaginativeness of Gotham utterly . The rules of this macrocosm were wholly arbitrary , and she was able-bodied to bring this latex - loving cat lady to life . She was aphrodisiac and seductive and played every view like she was do for the hearing . Her catsuit remains one of the best of all the looping .
As with many interesting characters , especially ones that have had as much of an impact on pop culture as Pfeiffer ’s Catwoman , the time came for a reboot . Halle Berry is a fine player , and on newspaper , she ticked every boxwood that the part required . She mostly suffered from a shallow script , and a general lack of conviction from most of the the great unwashed involved . The early 2000s were n’t kind to female person - led superhero films , and the 2004 version ofCatwomanwas a prime representative of that .
1Norman Bates
Anthony Perkins vs Vince Vaughan
Alfred Hitchcock was a visionary of his time , and has directed some of the most compelling while of cinema in history . The Birds , Rear Window , and , of course , Psycho , completely changed the way horror and thrillers were shot . Audiences of the prison term never knew what to expect , and the level of fear and malaise he was able to create was 2nd to none . take the " main protagonist " die in the first act of the plastic film was unheard of , so after Janet Leigh ’s ill-famed exhibitioner fit , viewers were left dumb . The shocking wrench at the oddment was surrender brilliantly by Anthony Perkins , who made the consultation feel nervous throughout the entire film .
It was Perkins who command the screen in every human activity , creating one of the most worrying on - screen characters . The 1998 Gus Van Sant remake attempt to recreatePsycho , shot by shot , allegedly as an court to the original . Vince Vaughan lacks any of Perkins ' foreboding intensity level and gets lose in the cast and the account . The film was largely panned , with the consensus being that it probably should not have been remade .
